Judas | Ask Fr Francis

Judas

Is Judas in Heaven or in hell? What if he did repent after he placed the rope on his neck but could not have physically affording to get off the rope. Did the Church, or Her prophets and saints, ever discussed about Judas’ final fate?

Is Judas in Heaven or in hell? What if he did repent after he placed the rope on his neck but could not have physically affording to get off the rope. Did the Church, or Her prophets and saints, ever discussed about Judas’ final fate?

為甚麼福音記載『隨著那片餅，撒殫進入了他的心』來敘述猶達斯的背負行動呢？我有些混淆，耶穌蘸的餅不是代表了祂的聖體嗎？那麼，聖體怎麼會被撒殫「騎劫」了？

為甚麼福音記載『隨著那片餅，撒殫進入了他的心』來敘述猶達斯的背負行動呢？我有些混淆，耶穌蘸的餅不是代表了祂的聖體嗎？那麼，聖體怎麼會被撒殫「騎劫」了？

On Holy Thursday, I remember the gospel reading of John 13:27, it says after Judas received the piece of bread, Satan entered him: how can that be possible when Jesus has given him the bread ( body of Christ) ?! I felt really puzzled about it, I thought with Jesus in you, the devil should have no chance!

On Holy Thursday, I remember the gospel reading of John 13:27, it says after Judas received the piece of bread, Satan entered him: how can that be possible when Jesus has given him the bread ( body of Christ) ?! I felt really puzzled about it, I thought with Jesus in you, the devil should have no chance!

假設猶達斯有自由意志去陷害耶穌。如果猶達斯没有陷害耶穌，天主的計劃還可以完成嗎? 又是否會有另一個人去陷害耶穌?

假設猶達斯有自由意志去陷害耶穌。如果猶達斯没有陷害耶穌，天主的計劃還可以完成嗎? 又是否會有另一個人去陷害耶穌?

假如猶大出賣了耶穌，為何上帝還眷顧猶太人？再者為何上帝或耶穌早知猶大是叛徒卻不加阻止？最後耶穌被釘十字架，這是否上帝安排一場「悲天憫人」的戲？

假如猶大出賣了耶穌，為何上帝還眷顧猶太人？再者為何上帝或耶穌早知猶大是叛徒卻不加阻止？最後耶穌被釘十字架，這是否上帝安排一場「悲天憫人」的戲？

究竟魔鬼進入了猶達斯的心讓他出賣耶穌，是簡單的促使他做背叛的壞事，如同世人今天受引誘出賣朋友一樣，還是針對耶穌而來要令衪被釘死？如果是後者，豈不是幫了耶穌一把讓衪以死贖世？從魔鬼試探耶穌的章節看來，魔鬼似乎是知道耶穌打算以自己的苦難救世的。這裡面的邏輯我有點搞不清。

究竟魔鬼進入了猶達斯的心讓他出賣耶穌，是簡單的促使他做背叛的壞事，如同世人今天受引誘出賣朋友一樣，還是針對耶穌而來要令衪被釘死？如果是後者，豈不是幫了耶穌一把讓衪以死贖世？從魔鬼試探耶穌的章節看來，魔鬼似乎是知道耶穌打算以自己的苦難救世的。這裡面的邏輯我有點搞不清。