問 Q: Is it ok or is it wrong as a Catholic to believe that in some cases, the desire to homosexuality is not a sin, but only the act to have sex with same sex or marry a same sex is a sin?

04/24/2020

【 問題來自Question from】 Canada 加拿大 | Other 其他

程明聰神父答Fr. Francis' Answer:

What you were describing about homosexual desire is more accurately described as a disposition, or a tendency, or a propensity to lean towards. People who have such disposition but do not act on it are called people with same-sex attraction. It is not a sin,in fact it is not even wrong, for someone to have an inordinate attraction. Same-sex attraction is a disorder, kind of like a sickness or handicap. The person did not choose it.

In a way, depression, which you also mentioned, is the same. Depression is a mental disorder, which limits or if severe even impedes the person from making sound or positive decisions. The person did not choose this condition and is not free to make responsible decisions. He or she cannot be held sinful for actions chosen under severe depression.

關鍵字 Keywords: homosexuality